427 St. John's Pl/Bet Underhill and Washington
Subject: 427 St. John's Pl/Bet Underhill and Washington
Hi Folks,427 St. John's Pl has condo has apartments for sale in this pre-war building.
The building has section 8 tenants that are being offered a chance to buy, and thus far 8 of 16 apartments are for sale.
Any thoughts on the building, the circumstances and the block. The condo apartments seem nice and enough and reasonably priced, but 'm wonderng if anyone has thoughts or experience with the gentrification of owners and renters in the same building, and whether the block, and neighborhood is safe.
Clearly the proximity to Prospect Park, the Farmers Market, and transportation are plusses, but I also want to get a sense of where things are with respect to the transition this area is going thru.
Thanks
Comments
-
While I don't live on that block or in that building, I own in a co-op building that changed under similar circumstances. For the most part, it's been smooth and everyone, while not the best of friends, gets along peacefully. Also, no one has been displaced, meaning that the rental units are sold to new owners only after tenants leave voluntarily.
As far as St. Johns Place is concerned, there have been many complaints on this board over the years about noise, especially during the warmer months. There have also been posts about shootings around the corner on Washington Avenue, but those incidents seem to be more the exception than the rule. The block also has its share of proponents, so I'm sure that opinions will vary from one person to the next. -
Some prior discussion about that building:
http://www.brooklynian.com/forums/viewtopic.php?p=33012&highlight=&sid=918679766951b255da7db976bdfdfc33 -
Hmmn, so Washington Ave is not quite where Vanderbilt is, in terms of civil diversity, though there is the Police station on Washington. Tom's restaurant and a few others seem to be thriving, and Underhill seems to be residential.
Read about an incident at Underhill Park, so I wonder if this block's transition
is closer to the slower place of Crown Heights or the more stable transition
of Prospect Heights closer to Flatbush Avenue.
The prices at 427 St. John's are priced in my ballpark, considering the size:
http://www.ahbrooklyn.com/property.php?id=616&type=coop&displaytype=coop
Just wondering whether I'm thinking of stepping into a building/block/neighborhood that is in the midst of being comfortable diverse or culturally contentious, in part because of the economic downturn. -
harrytrav wrote: Just wondering whether I'm thinking of stepping into a building/block/neighborhood that is in the midst of being comfortable diverse or culturally contentious, in part because of the economic downturn.
Gentrification on that block has always been contentious, even during the height of the boom. -
For what it's worth, I believe this building is one of the first in from Washington Avenue, so if the block turns out to be uncomfortable, you can easily avoid the rest of it. I believe that this area will only continue to become more gentified. As it stands, the economy sucks, yet businesses catering to the college-educated newcomers continue to open. The area has already seen major changes in the past five years.
-
Thanks Jack and Carnivore,
As a life long Brooklyn resident, I'm still somewhat conflicted by gentrification when it means a loss of the neighborhood history, culture and feel. Especially when it comes with a sense of exclusion. On the other hand, now that I can afford to buy I'm looking forward to enjoying the benefits of diversity, with nice neighborhood amenities, i.e. the proximity to prospect park, the museum, farmers market, etc..
I typically hate it when I react stereotypically. For example, I've seen folk who fit the undesirable descriptive stereotype profile, without any factual information, just standing in front of 427 St. John's, and I've immediately thought the worst. On the other hand, during open houses at the location, some of the residents seem perfectly neighborly.
In general, the area doesn't seem to be rough around the edges at all. Seems to be a much better location than Crown Heights, and not nearly as expensive as Fort Greene or Park Slope. Though it doesn't have the amenities of these areas, its close enough the what Fort Greene and park Slope offers.
Bottom line, the drop in prices had made for some interesting choices--but I need a place sooner rather than later. I guess I'll just have to get a sense of the preponderance of info and feelings from others on this area to get a sense of where my risk/benefit tolerence falls.
Any further thoughts are welcome. -
I woouldn't move into this building if the apartment was free---this is a total buyer beware situation.
-
Yea, but you're a snob. Plus, you're hot!
-
I lived on St Johns between Underhill and Washington -- sort of in the middle. I almost always avoided the Washington Ave end. Almost always.
Down at the "good end" there were the guys smoking weed and drinking brown-bag liquor in front of the buildings all summer... but they seemed harmless enough. (Never shared though). But the guys that were hanging around the Washington Ave end of the block... totally sketchy. I think the cops were trying to increase foot patrols down there, but not enough. I think I went down there 10 times after dark in two years -- every time I did not feel safe.
Now, if the guys at the other end would just stop throwing chicken bones on the sidewalk and clean up the huge piles left by their dogs.... -
I live on the next block, just off of Underhill, and I walk down that block all the time to go to places on Washington. I've never had a problem. However, incidents of violent crime have definitely continued to occur there with some regularity over the past few years despite the supposed gentrification (or according to some, because of it).
-
427 is one of the building where i see tenants open their windows and literally drop trash bags full of garbage out the window.
i don't know. -
i say buy the condo. i live a couple buildings away from that one and although there are always the said groups of people hanging out in front drinking and smoking, i've never been bothered by them, too much.
as for the clear avoidance of washington ave. i have always wondered, in the morning, when i'm walking to washington to go take the 2,3 on eastern parkway, if everyone else is just walking to the Q for the sole reason of being uncomfortable to walk on washington ? -
on second thought.. that may also be the building where people keep disposing their mattresses and furniture due to bed bugs. ha.
-
The renovations on those apartments are shoddy. They did nothing more than paint the walls and put in cheap appliances. The remaining apartments will be inhabited by Section 8 tenants. Yesterday I witnessed two kids heckling a potential buyer as he was talking to the real estate agent. And honestly, let's take the loitering, garbage, pot smoking, drinking, car-radio blasting out of the equation for a second. What about the overall upkeep of the building? The boiler, the roof, the foundation of the building...FWIW, the sponsors are offering financing---so prospective buyers won't have to deal with the banks. That should tell you alot about the overall value of the apartments---Chances are, the units would never appraise for the asking price by a legitimate lending organization. I said it before and I'll say it again: BUYER BEWARE.
-
thanks for the feedback. FWIW, 8 of the 16 apartments are empty. The remaining 8 apartments are Section 8 occupied. The owner has opted out of the Section 8 program in this building, and another on the same block. Look for the permit signs in the doors on the building down the block. The remaining tenants at 427 St. John's are not being evicted, and have an opportunity to buy.
On 4 separate trips to the apartment I've meant some of the occupants, and they seemed friendly enough. Many expressed delight with the upgrades to the building. They responded easily and positively when asked about the building and the neighborhood. At this juncture, I wouldn't mind having them as neighbors. To be balanced though, on a couple of occasions inquiries to the younger teenage types were met with an "I can't be bothered look". I've also seen a couple of the teen types standing in the front of the building on occasion. Certainly not a pleasant sight, as it reinforces prevailing negative stereotypes. Until I have real circumstances to deal with---I prefer not to give into fear. I'm a native New Yorker--maybe that helps. Besides, initially, I don't don't plan on living in front of the building much. If I do linger in the front of the building, I wonder what stereotype I'll fall into as an owner?
Roof has been inspected recently, and a new boiler is being installed. There are no active violations on file with DOB. The renovation, and I've seen a few in my day, could not be characterized as shoddy. Essentially, the apartments have been scrubbed, and are easily in the same class (pre-war building) as smaller apartments for more $$ on Underhill, Sterling and Butler. What the apartments lack, are high, or psuedo high-end kitchen and bathroom appliances and fixtures. I'd plan on adding these items, if thats your thing. Also the galley kitchens could easily be be opened up. The available units have already been appraised, and the building has been approved by major lenders without sponsor financing, though it is available for those that need it. For the price, including the +/- issues, I consider it a good buy. Of course, if you still have the mindset of flipping something here in 2- 3 years, that could be another story.
As you might have guessed, I've now put an offer in at 427 St. John's. I'm not totally unfamiliar with the area, as I do know a few people who live in the area, and I live nearby myself. I know that there are risks, and that clearly, class, cultural and racial gentrification can be tricky. As such, I will appreciate any further comments about the area, and the process in play at this building. Especially appreciated are comments from people who recognize that these kind of successes are happening, and that for the most part friendly civility can create a collective and be contagious. If anyone wants to PM me, feel free.
-
its a good block ive lived there all my live and though i am not one of the guys that smokes and drinks in front of the building i do hang with them and we only talk and joke no one ever intends on hurting anyone or has any malice in our hearts feel free to stop by and take a puff and make jokes with us were there all summer you can even say i referred you.
-
I'd say that earleydog1 is representative of the vast majority of the residents of that block.
-
earleydog1 wrote:
stop by and take a puff and make jokes with us were there all summer you can even say i referred you.
thanks dog, that's enough to make all of us new arrivals feel all warm and fuzzy. -
this is also the building that has the INSANELY loud parties in the back yard that shake all of the buildings on washington ave b/t sterling and st johns. only happens 3-4 times a summer though.
also, i have to wonder where folks who are scared of washington ave have been living previously. seems ridiculous. -
I like washington Ave. nothing wrong with it. Go back to 1987 and we'll talk.
-
this is the same building where guys have offered me free drugs in exchange for sex.
-
Curious to know how you handled the offer?
Some adolescents (teens or adults) haven't graduated to engaging a civil discourse, in a bar or similar venue, where such issues are often discussed in a more subtle manner....mostly over drinks and dinner.
So do you think the kids thought they were being cool, while actually being crude, or did you actually feel threatened by aggressively lewd language and behavior? Since I'm buying at the location, I want to get a sense. I may have to suggest to my female visitors to ask the young men if their mothers know they are disrespecting grown women, or to simply keep it moving and then call the cops. Beyond that, I don't think further engagement would be recommended.
If these kind of questions have previously yielded positive results for these guys, its becoming a shrinking demographic for them. As new owners and folk move into the building and area, I don't think similar inquiries will be received passively.
Howdy, Stranger!
Categories
- 40K All Categories
- 27.1K Neighborhoods
- 5.1K Crown Heights/Prospect Lefferts Gardens
- 7.1K Prospect Heights
- 2.3K Fort Greene, Clinton Hill, Bed-Stuy
- 8K Park Slope
- 549 Williamsburg, Greenpoint, Bushwick
- 442 Flatbush/Midwood/Ditmas Park
- 657 BoCoCa (Boerum Hill, Cobble Hill, Carroll Gardens)
- 151 Red Hook
- 104 Gowanus
- 304 Bay Ridge/Bensonhurst
- 130 Coney Island, Brighton Beach, Sheepshead Bay
- 270 Brooklyn Heights, DUMBO and Downtown
- 598 Windsor Terrace / Kensington
- 673 Greenwood Heights and Sunset Park
- 749 Brooklyn and Beyond
- 6.3K Stuff
- 86 Brooklyn Back When
- 1.2K Brooklyn Pets
- 257 Brooklyn Kids
- 241 Brooklyn Eats
- 51 Brooklyn Booze
- 3.6K The Lounge / Random Stuff
- 611 Brooklyn Politics
- 122 Brooklyn Sports and Fitness
- 111 Brooklyn Photos
- 339 Site Issues
- 8 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- 6.2K Listings
- 1.1K APARTMENTS and REAL ESTATE
- 1.3K Sales Openings Events
- 2.3K The Classifieds




