New bar from owners of Milk and Honey

Subject: Re: New bar from owners of Milk and Honey

BrookFetish wrote: So, what is the deal with this place (supposedly opening on Vanderbilt)...where exactly will it be, and when exactly will it open?

No idea of what you're talking about.

Keep movin' folks, nothin' to see here...

Why is it such a secret?

Rumor has it - it is in the building next to Evelyn??

interesting. perhaps, on my way home tonight, I'll peer into random windows between bergen & pacific on vandy for clues.

I was noticing a promising little storefront in progress today that looked like it could have been the spot... the space next to that Claudines cleaners, across the street from joyce. Is that where its gonna be??? on Vandy between Prospect and Park?

http://nymag.com/daily/food/2008/01/prospect_heights_cocktail_den_promises_back_garden_oysters.html

does this make y'all happy? Sounds like a promising addition to the nabe.

Shhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh.

quig wrote: It looks like I'll never have to cross Flatbush.

if it weren't for the weekly charity poker tourney at cattyshack, I would NEVER cross flatbush. my goal is to transplant that bar across flatbush (not happening, I know) so that I never have to leave the nabe again. well. except for that pesky work thing.

in any case, I LOVE cocktails and oysters. hurrah!

sprite wrote: To me, everything sounds great EXCEPT for the cocktails. I'll drink one occasionally, but I prefer beer or wine. Bars that specialize in cocktails are usually too chichi for me. Plus they tend to be expensive.

But cocktails are kind of the raison d'etre of Milk and Honey (and presumably this spinoff).

To me, everything sounds great EXCEPT for the cocktails. I'll drink one occasionally, but I prefer beer or wine. Bars that specialize in cocktails are usually too chichi for me.

I'd wager they'll also have beer, and good brew at that.

http://www.brownstoner.com/brownstoner/archives/2008/01/streetlevel_wea.php

Nice!

Carnivore wrote: That comment section is ridiculous. I'm glad we don't allow guest posting on the PS or PH boards here anymore.

Seriously! By the end I was wondering if they were all posted by the same bored troll....

Subject: weathered up will take your money!!!

I know many of you are very excited about this new cocktail lounge opening up, but knowing my neighborhood and many of the people on this board who complain about soda and other bars lack service, expensive beer, lack of happy hour etc. How many of you will be happy paying $10 to $14 dollars for a cocktail, and god knows how much they will charge for an oyster? So i know most of you are big drinkers 4 cocktails plus tip about $50 dollars and throw in half a dozen oysters, make it $70 dollars, i know soda, Mooney's, Tavern, Barrette and even beast which is not my favorite are not top notch places, but with $70 bucks i can have more than 12 drinks plus buy backs, why waste money on this place that will rob you for a cocktail and will not be as welcoming as the other bars mentioned above? So my question is will this place for all the press and talk around it, will it succeed or will it fail at its own pretentiousness and vanity?

Subject: Re: weathered up will take your money!!!

kaki wrote: I know many of you are very excited about this new cocktail lounge opening up, but knowing my neighborhood and many of the people on this board who complain about soda and other bars lack service, expensive beer, lack of happy hour etc. How many of you will be happy paying $10 to $14 dollars for a cocktail, and god knows how much they will charge for an oyster? So i know most of you are big drinkers 4 cocktails plus tip about $50 dollars and throw in half a dozen oysters, make it $70 dollars, i know soda, Mooney's, Tavern, Barrette and even beast which is not my favorite are not top notch places, but with $70 bucks i can have more than 12 drinks plus buy backs, why waste money on this place that will rob you for a cocktail and will not be as welcoming as the other bars mentioned above? So my question is will this place for all the press and talk around it, will it succeed or will it fail at its own pretentiousness and vanity?

I will definitely be there. If the quality lives up to the prices, I'll be there a lot. If not, I won't.

Just because the Manhattan couterparts of this bar charge high prices does not necessarily mean that Weather Up will do the same. In the end, they are a business and if they overprice their product, people will stop going. This will force Weather Up to rethink their approach and adjust accordingly, as reducing prices is favorable to going out of business.

I also question whether the tendency to complain, so prevalent on these boards, is indicative of neighborhood sentiment. After all, most residents of Prospect Heights or Crown Heights, new or old, rich or poor, and regardless of race or gender, have never heard of Brooklynian.com.